OpEx pass-through leakage in CRE acquisitions: where it hides and how to catch it early
OpEx pass-through leakage is the gap between what the leases let an owner recover and what actually gets billed and collected. It usually comes from CAM caps that changed through amendments, exclusions applied at the wrong level, or vendor contracts that escalate faster than the lease lets the owner recover. In acquisition diligence it's easy to miss, so buyers can end up underwriting recoveries the asset doesn't produce.
Even a modest annual shortfall in recoveries adds up once you capitalize it across a hold period. Medical office, complex retail and multi-tenant office are the most exposed, because they combine specialized operating costs, layered amendments and reimbursement structures that are more complicated than a standard office lease.
Where leakage hides: CAM caps, amendments and conflicting obligations
Leakage rarely sits in one clause. It usually shows up where CAM caps, amendment history and third-party service contracts interact.
Here's a common pattern. The original lease sets a non-cumulative cap on controllable CAM tied to a base year. A later amendment resets the base year, takes certain services out of the cap and adds an exception for amortized capital improvements. Another amendment gives a major tenant temporary relief during a build-out. Meanwhile the accounting system keeps applying the original cap as if none of that happened.
From the outside the recoveries can look reasonable, with year-over-year increases in an expected range. The calculation underneath can still be wrong. The system may never have picked up the reset base year, it may apply exclusions at the building level instead of the tenant level, or it may cap expenses that should sit outside the cap.
Vendor contracts make it worse. Janitorial, waste, HVAC and other service agreements often have annual escalators or minimum commitments that don't line up with the lease reimbursement terms. If a contract rises faster than the lease lets the owner recover, the difference becomes a recurring unrecoverable expense. A high-level abstract won't show that, but the cash flow will.
None of these conflicts is unusual. They're easy to overlook when a team is working through a large document set on a compressed closing timeline.
Why medical office is especially exposed
Medical office and other complex multi-tenant buildings have costs that generic CAM assumptions don't handle well: extended HVAC hours, specialized janitorial, biohazard disposal, enhanced security and higher utility use. If those costs aren't isolated correctly in the lease and the reconciliation, they leak every year.
Typical pressure points:
- After-hours HVAC for surgery or imaging billed at standard office rates, even though the lease allows premium recovery
- Waste contracts escalating faster than the applicable CAM cap
- Suite-specific janitorial or clinical support services folded into "building standard" expenses through later amendments
- Specialized services that should be billed directly to a tenant ending up in the general CAM pool or treated as non-recoverable
Each of these changes how recoveries perform over time. When the lease structure, amendment history and vendor economics aren't reconciled together, a buyer can inherit an asset that recovers less than underwriting assumed.
Why traditional lease audits often miss it
Most acquisition lease reviews are built for speed and coverage. They confirm economic terms, check dates, review a sample of reconciliations and flag obvious exceptions. That work is necessary, but it won't find most pass-through leakage, because leakage usually lives in the math rather than the headline fields.
A traditional abstract may note that a lease has a controllable CAM cap, and even the percentage. It usually doesn't work out how the cap operates over time, how later amendments changed it, whether exceptions apply by tenant or by expense type, or whether billing actually reflects those changes.
In multi-tenant portfolios the lease stack reflects years of operational change, so buyers are really reviewing versioned logic spread across:
- Base leases plus multiple amendments
- CAM definitions that changed with regulation or building code
- Older vendor contracts whose obligations outlast the lease language they were written against
Under time pressure, teams rely on sampling and rules of thumb. That catches overbilling risk and unusual language, but it often misses underbilling that's built into the asset's operating history.
An illustrative example: a medical office acquisition
This example is illustrative, but the issues in it come up again and again in complex multi-tenant assets.
A buyer is diligencing a medical office building. At a high level the leases and operating history look orderly. Once you review reimbursement across the full document set, it gets more complicated.
Rather than stopping at the abstracted fields, the review rebuilds how reimbursement actually worked over time: cap mechanics, amendment changes, expense carve-outs, and how lease rights interact with the service contracts. Then it tests those findings against historical operating expenses and billing.
That surfaces several likely sources of leakage: reimbursement terms that changed through amendments, medical-specific costs that need more precise allocation, and vendor contract economics that don't match expected recoveries. Once those are quantified, the buyer can refine underwriting, prioritize post-close billing adjustments and see where recovery risk sits in the asset.
A diligence playbook for OpEx leakage
Catching leakage mostly comes down to process. These are the five steps I'd use:
-
Define the recovery thesis before opening the data room.
Write down the recovery assumptions in your underwriting, including the expected reimbursement profile for controllable OpEx and the cap structures that support it. -
Reconstruct the lease logic behind the fields.
For major tenants, map how reimbursement works across the full document set: cumulative or non-cumulative caps, base year resets, exclusions, carve-outs and amendment-specific overrides. -
Crosswalk vendor contracts against reimbursement limits.
Find service agreements with escalators, minimums or specialized scopes that may outpace what the lease lets you recover. -
Use automation where the document logic gets too dense to review by hand.
The point is to turn lease provisions into structured obligations you can test against actual operating history. -
Quantify the impact.
Put a number on each mismatch: annual under-recovery, underwriting impact, and the specific steps available after closing to correct or mitigate it.
Catch it before closing
OpEx leakage rarely becomes a headline issue until after closing, and by then it's an asset management problem. My view is that recoveries should be treated as a logic exercise in diligence. When you reconcile lease structure, amendment history, vendor economics and historical billing together, the leakage shows up before it's built into your basis.
If you want to see how these issues can surface in practice, read the ABJNY case study.
Joe Leach
Founder & CEO
Elysium
www.elysium-cre.com